Diplomatic Interactions

Diplomatic Interactions

Comparative Economic Diplomacy: Iran and Egypt within the BRICS Framework

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD Student, Department of Political Science, Guilan University, Rasht, Iran.
2 PhD Student, Department of International Relations, Allameh Tabataba'i University, Tehran, Iran.
3 Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, University of Guilan, Rasht, Iran.
Abstract
Introduction
The concept of BRICS was initially introduced in 2001, and the group was formally established in 2009 by five emerging economies: Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa. Since then, its membership has expanded to include additional countries. BRICS is a coalition of emerging powers seeking to increase their influence in global political and economic decision-making. Unlike traditional international organizations, BRICS does not operate under a founding charter or a formalized institutional bureaucracy.
At the 15th BRICS Summit held in Johannesburg in August 2023, six countries—Iran, Argentina, Ethiopia, the United Arab Emirates, Saudi Arabia, and Egypt—were invited to join the group. Iran and Egypt officially became members in January 2024, with their first participation as full members taking place during the Kazan Summit in November 2023.
Although BRICS pursues collective goals, each member’s accession reflects its distinct national interests and strategic calculations. This article conducts a comparative analysis of Iran and Egypt’s objectives in joining BRICS. Accordingly, the central research question is: How can the economic diplomacy goals of Iran and Egypt be compared and explained within the framework of BRICS membership?
Literature Review
 
In the article “BRICS Expansion in the Middle East from the Political Economy Perspective”, the authors explore the interests of BRICS countries in securing energy resources, exerting political influence, and accessing the region’s economic potential. El Khodary and her colleagues specifically investigate the impact of Egypt’s accession to BRICS by analyzing several key indicators: the participation rate of BRICS countries in Egypt’s economy, the exposure rate and share of BRICS foreign direct investment (FDI) in Egypt relative to total FDI, as well as Egypt’s export opportunities in BRICS markets. Their study further examines how these variables have influenced the ratio of foreign assets in Egypt during the period from 2000 to 2024.
 
As the literature review indicates, existing studies—including the aforementioned work—differ from the present article in terms of research focus and problem formulation. This study aims to comparatively assess Iran and Egypt’s approaches to BRICS membership through the lens of economic diplomacy.
Methodology
 
The research method employed in this article is comparative-analytical, and data collection is based on library and documentary sources. Information and data have been gathered through literature review and note-taking techniques. The conceptual framework of the study draws upon the work of Mireya Solís Okano-Heijmans, particularly her insights on economic diplomacy.
Results
The findings of this study suggest that Iran’s objectives within BRICS are more politically driven, whereas Egypt’s motivations are primarily economic. Specifically, Iran views BRICS as a platform to advance multilateralism—a political strategy aimed at counterbalancing Western structural pressures, particularly from the United States. In contrast, Egypt’s engagement is largely focused on diversifying its economic partnerships and attracting foreign investment.
This divergence stems from the distinct political and economic constraints facing each country. While Iran seeks to mitigate geopolitical pressures and enhance its diplomatic flexibility through multilateralism, Egypt aims to expand its access to international markets and reduce dependency on traditional partners.
Nevertheless, both countries share common objectives, most notably the pursuit of economic and political multilateralism. Furthermore, BRICS membership offers new avenues for cooperation and strategic autonomy. For both Tehran and Cairo, joining the bloc represents an opportunity to explore “new options” for advancing national development and economic growth.
Discussion
In a comparative analysis of the economic diplomacy goals of Iran and Egypt, it seems that Iran's first and second priorities for joining BRICS are mainly political, while Egypt's first to third priorities are mainly economic. However, benefiting from the capacity of the BRICS Bank is one of the goals shared by Iran and Egypt, which is the third priority for both countries.
 
Conclusion
 
This article aimed to comparatively examine the economic diplomacy goals of the Islamic Republic of Iran and the Arab Republic of Egypt, as two of the newly admitted members of BRICS. One key finding is that the differing political and economic constraints faced by Iran and Egypt have shaped their respective motivations for joining the bloc. For Iran, membership in BRICS represents a strategic effort to reduce structural pressures, particularly those stemming from U.S. sanctions—and to promote multilateralism as a counterbalance to American unilateralism. Conversely, Egypt’s accession is primarily motivated by economic considerations, such as diversifying its international partners and expanding access to new markets.
 
Another notable conclusion is that countries tend to be more effective in pursuing economic diplomacy when they (1) broaden the scope of their diplomatic engagements, (2) adopt innovative strategies, and (3) discontinue ineffective or outdated practices.
 
The findings also highlight BRICS as a platform with considerable potential across economic, trade, industrial, technological, and financial sectors. Given Iran’s unique situation—particularly its continued exposure to Western sanctions—joining BRICS could offer valuable opportunities to reinvigorate its development trajectory. However, realizing these opportunities requires a comprehensive assessment of both the prospects and the challenges ahead to maximize alignment with national interests.
 
Keywords

Subjects


Affan, Manal Mohamed El-Hassanein; El-Shaarawy, Mustafa El-Sayed; El-Gazzar, Farouk Fathy; and Waddan, Doaa Soliman Mohamed (2023), The Economic Impacts of the BRICS Group on the International Payments System: An Analytical Study of Egypt, Scientific Journal of Commercial Research (Menoufia University), Volume 49, Issue 2, Part 2, April 2023, pp. 711-768. [In Arabic]
- Cairo 24 (2023), Prime Minister: Joining BRICS would provide Egypt with concessionary loans from the Development Bank, www.cairo24.com/1853695. [In Arabic]
- Egyptian Ministry of Finance (2023), Minister of Finance: Egypt's Accession to BRICS Enhances Investment and Export Opportunities and Foreign Inflows, www.mof.gov.eg. [In Arabic]
- Egyptian Presidency (2024), President Abdel Fattah El-Sisi's speech during the BRICS Plus Summit, https://www.presidency.eg. [In Arabic]
- Fakheri, Mehdi (2024), The Impact of BRICS Expansion on Approaches to the Global Economy and International Trade, Foreign Policy Quarterly, 38(2), 177-200. [In Persian]
- Information and Decision Support Center (2023), Egypt and BRICS Countries... Promising Opportunities, Egyptian Cabinet, Issue 20, December 2023. [In Arabic]
- IRNA (2024), Iran's foreign trade development policy with the BRICS group in the 14th government, available at: www.irna.ir/xjS5Bs date of access, 14/10/1403. [In Persian]
- IRNA (2024), Pezizkian: With the implementation of the achievements of the BRICS summit, the conspiracy of the United States and its allies will be neutralized, available at: www.irna.ir/xjRVQ2, date of access: 14/10/1403. [In Persian]
- Jamshidi, M., Heydari, N., & Fallahi, S. (2024). The Political Economy Approach to the Confrontation Model Between the Islamic Republic of Iran and the BRICS Organization. International Political Economy Studies, 7 (1), 135-148. http//doi.org/10.22126/ipes.2024.10290.1653. [In Persian]
- Ministry of Foreign Affairs (2024), Meeting and discussion between Mehdi Safari, Deputy Minister of Economic Diplomacy of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, on the sidelines of the BRICS Summit, with Ms. Dilma Rousseff, President of the New Development Bank, available at: www.mfa.gov.ir/portal/newsview/728108, date of access, 10/21/1403. [In Persian]
- Mirtorabi, Saeed & Fallah, Mehrdad (2022). China, BRICS and the Evolution of the Institutional Order of the Global Economy, International Political Economy Studies, 5 (2), 415-446.
- Mousavi Shefaei, Masoud; Hemmat, Imani (2017), Economic Diplomacy; An Approach to Increasing Iran's National Power, Strategy Quarterly, No. 84. [In Persian]
- Mousavi, Seyyed Mohammad Hadi; Mirtorabi Hosseini, Saeed; Ghorbani Sheikhneshin, Arsalan; Modarres, Mohammad Vali; (2019), BRICS’s Challenge with US Controlled World Financial Structure; Iranian Research Letter of International Politics, 8 (1). [In Persian]
- Noroozi H. (2024). “New Development Bank of BRICS; Contemplation on institutional rationality and functional attractiveness”. Countries Studies. 2(2): 73-78. doi: https://doi.org/10.22059/jcountst.2024.371704.1110. [In Persian]
- Presidential Center for Strategic Studies (2024), Meeting on Opportunities and Capacities of Iran's Presence in BRICS, available at: www.css.iripo.ir/Zu9e, date of access, 10/15/1403. [In Persian]
- Presidential website (2023), Dr. Raisi: Iran's membership in BRICS will strengthen the approaches of this group, including opposition to US unilateralism, available at: www.president.ir/fa/146259, date of access, 15/11/1403. [In Persian]
- Presidential website (2024), BRICS Plus must design and implement a transparent and inclusive mechanism with a special focus on developing countries, available at: www.president.ir/fa/154773, date of access, 11/25/1403. [In Persian]
- Sadeghi S. (2024). Iranian view on BRICS and developments in international system: Examining the research approaches of Iranian scientific-research articles on international relations. Countries Studies. 2(2): 55-58. https://doi.org/10.22059/jcountst.2024.369490.1086. [In Persian]
- Sagheb, H., Hosseini, M., & Moradi Haghighi, F. (2024). The feasibility of development and trade cooperation between Iran and the countries of the BRICS-PLUS: the case of manufacturing industries. International Political Economy Studies, 7 (1), 149-167. http//doi.org/10.22126/ipes.2024.10333.1654. [In Persian]
- Sajjadpour, Seyyed Mohammad Kazem; Hosseini, Seyyed Shams al-Din; Nirabadi, Hamid (2019), Designing the Model of Economic Diplomacy of the Islamic Republic of Iran Key Needs, Components, and Strategies, National Security Quarterly, Year 9, Issue 34, Winter. [In Persian]
- Salehi SH, Mousavi Shafaee SM, Golmohammadi V, Haji-Yousefi AM. (2024). “China's de-dollarization policy and its impact on the hegemony of the US dollar”. Countries Studies. 2(2): 47-54. doi: https://doi.org/10.22059/jcountst.2023.367816.1075.  [In Persian]
- Salimi, Hossein (2019), Seven Steps in Applied Research, Scientific Publication, First Edition. [In Persian]
- Samadzadeh Saber, Majid (2024), Khorasan Razavi Chamber of Commerce, Explanation of the long-term and medium-term impact of BRICS on the country's economy, available at: www.news.mccima.com/40091/, date of access, 11/10/1403. [In Persian]
- Zarandi, Saeed. (2024), An Overview of Comparative Research Methods: Theories, Approaches and Perspectives, Comparative Public Administration Quarterly, Year 1, Volume 1, Issue 4. [In Persian]